Friday, March 13, 2015

Reflections on the History of Jazz


My assumptions about the history of jazz have largely been reinforced but what I have learned in this class. I knew that jazz flourished in cities, particularly areas of vice, and I was aware of the general historical trajectory of styles of jazz. I was also aware Whites heavily have heavily appropriated this Black-created form of cultural production.  Though my assumptions were mostly reinforced, the course has certainly given me a much more nuanced understanding of these topics.  The racial tensions that have characterized the history of jazz, explored throughout the Miles Davis Autobiography, were particularly interesting to learn about.
            Miles Davis said of his grandfather, “When he bought all that land [500 acres], the white people in the area who had used him to straighten out their financial matters, their money books, turned against him. Ran him off his land. In their minds, a black man wasn’t supposed to have all that land and all that money. He wasn’t supposed to be smart, smarter than them. It hasn’t changed too much; things are like that even today” (Davis and Troupe, 12). This passage illustrates a racial dynamic present in much of the history of jazz; White audiences are content to consume the efforts and cultural production of Black people, but at the same time actively block Black creators from attaining “too much” remuneration for their work. For much of the 20th century, White jazz bands had a much easier time getting record deals, radio spots, and gigs at nicer clubs than black bands, despite the fact that every style of jazz was developed primarily by Black musicians. Gangsters would entrap Black musicians into unfair contracts where they received little for entertaining packed clubs night after night. The popularity of swing took off with the explosion of radio, yet producers of TV spots would hesitate to show the Black bands who wrote the popular radio hits people wanted to hear.  
            Though my broad assumptions about White appropriation of jazz were confirmed, this course gave me a much more nuanced understanding of how that phenomenon played out. It also helped me deepen my thinking about the issue of cultural appropriation generally, and where the demarcating line exists between appropriation and exchange. Before taking this course, I believed that any member of a dominant social group profiting from the cultural production of a marginalized group was cultural appropriation. Learning about figures such as Bix Biederbecke has complicated this idea and made me realize that situational and personal context is significant in the issue of appropriation.

Comment on Markell Stine’s blog

Friday, March 6, 2015

Jazz and Community

Robin Kelley’s biography of Thelonious Monk argues that rather than being an isolated and out-of-touch savant, Monk’s genius was both product and architect of community. Monk grew up in San Juan Hill, a very diverse but very segregated working class community. According to Kelley, tensions between racial groups in San Juan Hill were high and violence was common. Even so, the community within a borough was close-knit and full of music (Kelley, 20). This helps explain why Monk was dismissive of the black power and radical militancy movements; race conflict did not seem to be merely black versus white to him, and he witnessed the power of music to bring even a conflicted community together. In San Juan Hill, Monk had the opportunity to befriend and learn from older musicians such as James P. Johnson, who would teach him about their music for free. In addition, influences from the diverse street music he would have been exposed to (such as calypso and salsa) made their way into his music.
Bebop, to which Monk’s music was seminal, created a community that was largely different from the rest of the U.S. Reflecting the dramatic political and social transformation of the 40’s and 50’s, the bebop community was individualistic, modernist, bohemian, both bounded by and transcending race and class. Monk’s music, in particular, was transcendent in these respects. He was loved by a young generation of both blacks and whites that were rebelling against the strictures of American society and middle class conformity. Monk’s music created a bohemian community of artistic souls (Stewart, 2/14/15).
The relationship of jazz to the community in Leimert Park is similar to the one Kelley outlines. Jazz brought to Leimert Park a sense of community through art, of pride in one’s heritage, and activism in arts and culture. The World Stage and 5th Street Dick’s became spaces where the community gathered to engage in dialogue, both artistically and literally. Jazz and other arts also gave people the ability to express about racism, the struggles of working class life, tragedy, and other experiences. In the cases both of Leimart Park and the community around Monk’s music, jazz brought people together and gave them a way to express and uplift themselves.
There is a clear symbiosis between art and the communities in which jazz musicians grow up and perform. The community influences what a jazz musician creates; the musician responds to the social, political, and cultural atmosphere of the community. In turn, the community is influenced by the ethos of the music that comes out of it. 

Comment on Steenalisa’s post

Friday, February 13, 2015

Race in the Swing Era

The popularization of radio contributed to the emergence of a national market for jazz, resulting in the rise of a “jazz capitalism”. This, in addition to the long economic depression, made competition between white and black musicians, as well as the imbalance of power between them, much more blatant. As the racial tensions that had always existed in jazz finally became salient to more white people, race became explicitly written and talked about in the 1930’s “Swing Era”.

Through the magic of radio, Americans in the 1930s increasingly consumed entertainment from the comfort of their living rooms. This new mass medium spurred the popularity of jazz (specifically swing) to new heights and created a national market for it. But the change did no favors to most musicians, since “a single band could now entertain countless listeners…a few instrumentalists were doing the work that previously required hundreds, maybe thousands, of bands” (Gioia, 128). This greatly heightened competition between musicians.  Because white people controlled the means of production (including radio stations), and racism dictated a preference for white musicians, black musicians were at a distinct disadvantage in the competition. According to UCSB professor Jeffrey Stewart, “radio spots and gigs required deference to the rituals of Jim Crow segregation”, which usually meant that black musicians could not be in the front lines delivering the music beloved by white audiences to those same white audiences (February, 2015) These racial contradictions finally became quite blatant to those involved in the music industry.

The Great Depression caused many people to question the merits of capitalism. At the same time, the nationalization of jazz resulted in a kind of “jazz capitalism” increasingly characterized by fierce competition between workers (musicians) and the ownership of the musician’s labor (art) by a ruling class (whites arbiters of cultural distribution, particularly agents). The new critical view towards capitalist systems included jazz capitalism in its analytical gaze. As more people began to interpret the U.S. economy in Marxist terms (with a ruling class that owns the means of production exploiting the working class) it became easier for them to notice a parallel system occurring in jazz.

The popularization of radio, emergence of a national market for jazz, economic depression, increased competition, and emergence of “jazz capitalism” helped make racial tensions in jazz salient to white people, resulting in race become explicitly written and talked about during the Swing Era.


Commented on Shadee Barzin's post.  

Thursday, February 5, 2015

Harlem's New Jazz


Though New York and Chicago were both extremely important sites to the development of jazz, ultimately, New York was more responsible for catapulting jazz into the mainstream. New York’s greater economic power enticed a huge number of blacks to move there in the 1920s. The city was the most heterogeneous in the U.S. at that time, and included a longstanding black population that had acquired a degree of economic prosperity. In Harlem, in particular, “70% of real estate was under black control – with all the independence that ownership conveyed” (Gioia, 90). This certainly contributed to the flourishing of the arts and intellectualism that occurred during the Harlem Renaissance. For musicians, New York provided opportunities that weren’t available in Chicago. African American Revues provided black performance aesthetic access to the mainstream, as well as fame, money, and other gigs for black performers. These revues were extremely important to popularizing jazz as a mainstream music.
Despite this mainstream access, there was still a large amount of racial tension both in the city of New York and the production of jazz. In the best clubs, black cultural producers (jazz musicians) were being consumed by an exclusively white audience. Blackness had to be performed for whiteness in order to achieve success. And even despite the success of jazz, black culture was largely looked down upon by whites. White musicians still had much easier access to the means of music distribution than their black counterparts, in addition. 
            The social atmosphere of New York contributed both to the dissemination of jazz and the development of a new, uniquely New York style. The necessity of holding an audience’s attention in Harlem, where there were many other clubs close by, created in jazz a competitive ethos that is still strongly present today. According to Gioia, “In an age in which other art forms have come to eschew demonstrations of virtuosity, the jazz world continues to embrace one-upmanship and displays of technique as an integral part of its culture. To a great extent, the hothouse environment of Harlem helped produce this new image of the jazz musician as half artist, half warrior” (93). This competition also forced musicians to combine popular styles of music – European march and Southern ring-shout styles – which resulted in a new genre: stride. James P. Johnson, Fats Waller, and Fletcher Henderson were champions of stride style.  
            In addition to stride style, New York facilitated the development of another new element in jazz: the musician as larger-than-life multitalented entertainer. Fats Waller exemplifies this dynamic. “With unflagging exuberance, Waller talked, sang, joked, exhorted band members, and, almost as an afterthought, played piano….This was the quintessential party music for those who had come of age under prohibition….And audience loved it. Waller made them feel like they were honored guests at his party” (95). With his boisterous performances and recordings, his skill at piano soloing and composition, and his command of multiple styles, Walter’s music best represents the culture and community of Harlem.