My assumptions about the history of
jazz have largely been reinforced but what I have learned in this class. I knew
that jazz flourished in cities, particularly areas of vice, and I was aware of
the general historical trajectory of styles of jazz. I was also aware Whites
heavily have heavily appropriated this Black-created form of cultural
production. Though my assumptions were
mostly reinforced, the course has certainly given me a much more nuanced
understanding of these topics. The
racial tensions that have characterized the history of jazz, explored
throughout the Miles Davis Autobiography, were particularly interesting to
learn about.
Miles Davis said of his grandfather,
“When he bought all that land [500 acres], the white people in the area who had
used him to straighten out their financial matters, their money books, turned
against him. Ran him off his land. In their minds, a black man wasn’t supposed
to have all that land and all that money. He wasn’t supposed to be smart, smarter
than them. It hasn’t changed too much; things are like that even today” (Davis
and Troupe, 12). This passage illustrates a racial dynamic present in much of
the history of jazz; White audiences are content to consume the efforts and
cultural production of Black people, but at the same time actively block Black
creators from attaining “too much” remuneration for their work. For much of the
20th century, White jazz bands had a much easier time getting record
deals, radio spots, and gigs at nicer clubs than black bands, despite the fact
that every style of jazz was developed primarily by Black musicians. Gangsters
would entrap Black musicians into unfair contracts where they received little
for entertaining packed clubs night after night. The popularity of swing took
off with the explosion of radio, yet producers of TV spots would hesitate to
show the Black bands who wrote the popular radio hits people wanted to hear.
Though my
broad assumptions about White appropriation of jazz were confirmed, this course
gave me a much more nuanced understanding of how that phenomenon played out. It
also helped me deepen my thinking about the issue of cultural appropriation
generally, and where the demarcating line exists between appropriation and
exchange. Before taking this course, I believed that any member of a dominant
social group profiting from the cultural production of a marginalized group was
cultural appropriation. Learning about figures such as Bix Biederbecke has
complicated this idea and made me realize that situational and personal context
is significant in the issue of appropriation.
No comments:
Post a Comment